小男孩是三倍更有可能比短的女孩接受重组人生长激素治疗特发性矮小(ISS),即使在普通儿科人口同等比例的男女高度下降阈值指定空间站下。研究人员分析了超过283000名美国儿童和青少年的记录,在提供治疗的过程中发现了一个明确的和持续的性别偏见。
“成长是儿童健康的一个重要标志,所以生长衰竭优点平等考虑对于男孩和女孩,说:”研究的领导者负责人Adda Grimberg,MD,在费城儿童医院的儿科内分泌学家(CHOP)和宾夕法尼亚大学的伦纳德戴维斯卫生经济研究所高级研究员。“在处理性别偏见可能有双重的不良影响,短的女孩,有一个潜在的疾病可能被忽略,而短的健康的男孩可能会收到过分热心,用昂贵的药物,需要夜间注射年有潜在的副作用,不必要的治疗。”
格瑞姆伯格和同事将他们的研究发表在6月9日在线杂志科学报告。
The study team drew on health records from 28 primary care practices in the CHOP pediatric network, comprising 189,280 patients, and compared them to 93,736 patients from the four U。S。 pediatric growth hormone registries。 All the subjects were children and adolescents (up to age 20)。
In the primary care population, 2,073 subjects (1。1 percent of the total) had height below the threshold for idiopathic short stature (ISS) — short stature from an unknown cause。 There were no gender differences in the prevalence of height below this threshold, nor in the distributions of height in the entire primary care population。 The U。S。 Food & Drug Administration defines ISS as height more than 2。25 standard deviations below mean for age and gender, without evidence of underlying disease。 This statistical definition of height corresponds to the shortest 1。2 percent of the U。S。 population。
In contrast, among patients receiving recombinant human growth hormone for ISS, 74 percent were male。 Among patients who received the hormone for all diagnoses, 66 percent were male。 At the time of initiating growth hormone for ISS, treated boys outnumbered girls for every year of age starting at age 1, but the biggest differences occurred around puberty, when late bloomers and limited remaining time for potential medical intervention raise concern。
The authors note that both physicians and parents contribute to the gender-based treatment bias。 Grimberg and colleagues found in a 2005 study that twice as many boys as girls were referred to specialists for evaluation of short stature, and that girls who were referred had greater height deficits than boys who were referred。 Similarly, in the growth hormone registries in the current study, the girls treated for ISS were on average shorter than the treated boys at the start of growth hormone treatment。
The authors added that although primary care physicians make the referrals, they are influenced by parental concerns, and that some parents directly seek specialist care regarding short stature in their children。 “Social pressures regarding height seem to affect males more than females, at least in the U。S。,” said Grimberg。 “In the absence of an underlying condition, treating short children with recombinant human growth hormone represents medicalization of a physical trait。” Human growth hormone treatment costs roughly $20,000 annually per child and requires daily injections。
Finally, in previous research, Grimberg found that proportionally more girls who were referred for evaluation of short stature were much more likely to have an underlying disease than boys who were referred。 “The gender bias in referral and treatment suggests that diagnoses of underlying diseases are more likely to be delayed or missed altogether in short girls, and this suggests missed opportunities to address those conditions, not all of which require growth hormone treatment。”
The National Institutes of Health (grant HD057037 from the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development) supported this study, along with the Genentech Center for Clinical Research in Endocrinology。 Biostatistical guidance came from the University of Pennsylvania Clinical and Translational Science Award (NIH grant UL1TR000003 from the National Center for Research Resources and the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences)。
“Gender Bias in U。S。 Pediatric Growth Hormone Treatment,” 科学报告, published online June 9, 2015。 http://doi。org/10。1038/srep11099。
(注:转载时请注明复诊网)